Wednesday, January 11, 2012

Joins ( ANSI Vs Legacy )

I am not a big fan of ANSI style joins especially outer joins . For me , the SQL becomes large , applying hints is a bit problematic.
Some people would disagree with this . Their take is that is a standard ( I can't win on that ) and second , it is readable ( I have to say , this is subjective).For most of the queries written in ANSI way , Oracle translates itself in a legacy style ( like table1.column1 = table2.column1 (+) ... ) , if we look at the trace files.
Not all joins can be done in a legacy style . For example , FULL OUTER JOIN , PARTITION OUTER JOIN can be written only in ANSI style.
I try to use legacy joins , wherever possible :-)  
Here is an example .


SQL> create table zahir.emp as Select * from scott.emp; 
Table created.

SQL> create table zahir.dept as Select * from scott.dept;

Table created.

Example of Equi Join or Inner Join
-----------------------------------
SQL> select d.deptno , d.dname , e.empno , e.ename from dept d , emp e where d.deptno = e.deptno;
 
     DEPTNO DNAME               EMPNO ENAME
 ---------- -------------- ---------- ----------
         20 RESEARCH             7369 SMITH
         30 SALES                7499 ALLEN
         30 SALES                7521 WARD
         20 RESEARCH             7566 JONES
         30 SALES                7654 MARTIN
         30 SALES                7698 BLAKE
         10 ACCOUNTING           7782 CLARK
         20 RESEARCH             7788 SCOTT
         10 ACCOUNTING           7839 KING
         30 SALES                7844 TURNER
         20 RESEARCH             7876 ADAMS
         30 SALES                7900 JAMES
         20 RESEARCH             7902 FORD
         10 ACCOUNTING           7934 MILLER
         10 ACCOUNTING              7 James Bond
 
15 rows selected.
SQL> select d.deptno , d.dname , e.empno , e.ename from dept d  inner join emp e on ( d.deptno = e.deptno);

    DEPTNO DNAME               EMPNO ENAME
---------- -------------- ---------- ----------
        20 RESEARCH             7369 SMITH
        30 SALES                7499 ALLEN
        30 SALES                7521 WARD
        20 RESEARCH             7566 JONES
        30 SALES                7654 MARTIN
        30 SALES                7698 BLAKE
        10 ACCOUNTING           7782 CLARK
        20 RESEARCH             7788 SCOTT
        10 ACCOUNTING           7839 KING
        30 SALES                7844 TURNER
        20 RESEARCH             7876 ADAMS
        30 SALES                7900 JAMES
        20 RESEARCH             7902 FORD
        10 ACCOUNTING           7934 MILLER
        10 ACCOUNTING              7 James Bond

15 rows selected.

Example of Outer Join
---------------------
SQL> select d.deptno , d.dname , e.empno , e.ename from dept d , emp e where d.deptno = e.deptno (+);

    DEPTNO DNAME               EMPNO ENAME
---------- -------------- ---------- ----------
        20 RESEARCH             7369 SMITH
        30 SALES                7499 ALLEN
        30 SALES                7521 WARD
        20 RESEARCH             7566 JONES
        30 SALES                7654 MARTIN
        30 SALES                7698 BLAKE
        10 ACCOUNTING           7782 CLARK
        20 RESEARCH             7788 SCOTT
        10 ACCOUNTING           7839 KING
        30 SALES                7844 TURNER
        20 RESEARCH             7876 ADAMS
        30 SALES                7900 JAMES
        20 RESEARCH             7902 FORD
        10 ACCOUNTING           7934 MILLER
        10 ACCOUNTING              7 James Bond
        40 OPERATIONS

16 rows selected.


SQL> select d.deptno , d.dname , e.empno , e.ename from dept d  left outer join emp e on ( d.deptno = e.deptno);

    DEPTNO DNAME               EMPNO ENAME
---------- -------------- ---------- ----------
        20 RESEARCH             7369 SMITH
        30 SALES                7499 ALLEN
        30 SALES                7521 WARD
        20 RESEARCH             7566 JONES
        30 SALES                7654 MARTIN
        30 SALES                7698 BLAKE
        10 ACCOUNTING           7782 CLARK
        20 RESEARCH             7788 SCOTT
        10 ACCOUNTING           7839 KING
        30 SALES                7844 TURNER
        20 RESEARCH             7876 ADAMS
        30 SALES                7900 JAMES
        20 RESEARCH             7902 FORD
        10 ACCOUNTING           7934 MILLER
        10 ACCOUNTING              7 James Bond
        40 OPERATIONS

16 rows selected.


Example of Full Join
--------------------- 

Here is where , leacgy style doesn't work.

 SQL> select d.deptno , d.dname , e.empno , e.ename from dept d , emp e where d.deptno (+) = e.deptno (+);
select d.deptno , d.dname , e.empno , e.ename from dept d , emp e where d.deptno (+) = e.deptno (+)
                                                                                     *
ERROR at line 1:
ORA-01468: a predicate may reference only one outer-joined table


SQL> select d.deptno , d.dname , e.empno , e.ename from dept d  full outer join emp e on ( d.deptno = e.deptno);

    DEPTNO DNAME               EMPNO ENAME
---------- -------------- ---------- ----------
        20 RESEARCH             7369 SMITH
        30 SALES                7499 ALLEN
        30 SALES                7521 WARD
        20 RESEARCH             7566 JONES
        30 SALES                7654 MARTIN
        30 SALES                7698 BLAKE
        10 ACCOUNTING           7782 CLARK
        20 RESEARCH             7788 SCOTT
        10 ACCOUNTING           7839 KING
        30 SALES                7844 TURNER
        20 RESEARCH             7876 ADAMS
        30 SALES                7900 JAMES
        20 RESEARCH             7902 FORD
        10 ACCOUNTING           7934 MILLER
        10 ACCOUNTING              7 James Bond
        40 OPERATIONS
       

       
    Comments Welcome.

No comments:

Post a Comment